Showing posts with label The Robbers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Robbers. Show all posts

30.7.08

Is Atheism the Answer when God is the Question? Reading Schiller’s The Robbers from a contemporary atheist perspective


The question of whether god exists and criticisms of the socio-political effects of religious institutions is perhaps as old as god(s) and the institutions themselves.

Friedrich Schiller’s epic Enlightenment-era play
The Robbers continues to resonate to audiences at the dawn of the twenty-first century and is a powerful representation of the recurring arguments in atheist discourse, contrary to Schiller’s stated intentions for the play.

Recent contemporary atheist texts by Richard Dawkins, Michel Onfray and Christopher Hitchens, present an aggressive case against the three dominant monotheistic religions and attempt to open a dialogue concerning the new secular society they believe we are already shifting toward.

Comparing Schiller’s
The Robbers and these current atheist texts reveals some startling similarities that suggest atheism is the answer when god is in question.



TABLE OF CONTENTS

1) Introduction
2) Contemporary Atheists and their Critical Reception
3) Friedrich Schiller and The Robbers
4) Origins of Atheism
5) The Robbers and Contemporary Atheism
6) The Atheist in Dramatic texts
7) The Dangers of Knowledge and The Robbers
8) Heaven, Hell and The Robbers
9) Death, Beckett, Conscience and Reason, Corruption,
Heaven and Hell Rethought and The Robbers
10) A Brief Search for the Origins of God and Religion
11) Conclusion
12) Bibliography

Introduction

Dramatic texts from Ancient Greece to the present have contributed much to debates concerning the existence of god, religious dogma and their perceived imperfections and logic. Holding god and religion up to close scrutiny, these texts helped open the way for further avenues of enquiry and exploration of their profound effect on humanity. But while some playwrights have sought to question religious institutions, others have attempted to uphold religious principles with equal force. Poet, philosopher and playwright, Friedrich Schiller regarded himself as one of the latter. His first play
The Robbers (Die Raüber, 1783) is epic in scale and theme, which for the most part, asks legitimate questions about not only the existence of god but also the dubious nature of religion, its institutions and their corrupt collusion with the state. The play examines the nature of conscience and reason, reinforces religions fear of knowledge and the dangers of atheism. The fear of death, the cult of the virgin and the concepts of heaven and hell are also strengthened with dynamic potency. Contrary to Schiller’s stated intentions, The Robbers, portrays a stark reality with ample justification for cynicism toward god and religious institutions and perhaps is an unintended milestone in atheist discourse. Despite being an exigent attempt to present a powerful indictment of the power and righteousness of religion coupled with a dire warning of the dangers of impiety, it offers an insight into both the religious and atheistic mindset.

The question of whether god(s) exists or not is as old as the concept of god(s) itself: likewise the concept of atheism. For the most part official historical interpretations have tended to equate atheism with evil or immorality. Contemporary atheist texts such as Richard Dawkins’
The God Delusion (2006), Michel Onfray’s The Atheist Manifesto: A Case Against Christianity, Judaism and Islam (2007) and Christopher Hitchens’ God is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything (2007) endeavour to reconfigure the idea of atheism as quite the opposite. Using a vast spectrum of accumulated knowledge, from history, the arts, science and philosophy, these writers aggressively challenge the logic of an omniscient and omnipresent god, religion’s superstitious beliefs and its ineffective ritualistic practices. They highlight the corruption of religious institutions as well as the death and destruction committed in god’s name over two millennia. They also seek to open dialogue and imagine a new post-religious secular future as the next (perhaps unstoppable) evolutionary step for humankind.

With close consideration to contemporary perspectives espoused in Dawkins, Onfray and Hitchens, this thesis investigates whether these ideas compare with those of
The Robbers which, when it was first staged, caused outrage for being “the most blasphemous attack on religion in German literature up to that time” (Leidner:xiv). I explore several contentious ideas of Schiller’s contained in The Robbers viewed both in an historical context and within a contemporary atheistic paradigm. Given that many of these “blasphemous” arguments within The Robbers continue to persist today I wish to investigate the notion that when god is in question - whether now, in the Eighteenth century or any other time for that matter – if atheism, as we know it today, was, and still is, the answer.

Friedrich Schiller and The Robbers

Friedrich Schiller was part of the Sturm und Drang (Storm and Stress) literary movement in Germany during the mid to late eighteenth century. Although not an organised, self-conscious group with unifying philosophical and/or literary principles, their collective dramatic works, nevertheless, do contain similar traits. Taking inspiration from Shakespeare’s strong focus on character, Sturm und Drang writers, like Schiller, tended to create characters that were victims of their environment, reacting in either an explosive and violent way or with passive and chronic melancholy, or both. These writers did not focus solely on character but also on why a character develops the way it does within the realm of a broader moral and social order (Leidner:xi). In order to understand why these writers developed this unique perspective and style, a basic understanding of their social and political environment is required.

Germany during the eighteenth century was “a patchwork of some three hundred tiny states”, most ruled by “Fursten” who, while not actually being royalty, were “sovereigns in their own right” (Leidner: vii). This socio/political situation had arisen during the latter part of the seventeenth century establishing an “extravagant baroque court culture” which was to be a major source of contention in coming years (Sharpe:6). Not only was Parliament composed of clergy, wealthy established families, military and other civic figures, but it used an outdated constitution and system from the previous century. To add further tension, in 1773 Pope Clemens XIV abolished the Jesuit order. The Jesuits were a very well respected across Germany, including the people of the Swabian district, where Schiller grew up. The foundations of society were increasingly unstable as the ruling hierarchy were becoming more at odds and out of touch with the wider, and much poorer, community. This cultural and social shift, along with the socio/political ascent of a new middle-class created the basis for an aggressive and scrupulous critique of German society using the theatrical stage as its platform. Schiller was a major force in this nascent movement and created a unique style and point of view that continues to resonate over two hundred years later.

When Schiller’s first play
The Robbers was first performed at the Mannheim National Theatre in 1783, the reaction was verging on the hysterical as one eyewitness report noted: “The Theatre was like a madhouse: rolling eyeballs, clenched fists, stamping feet, hoarse cries in the auditorium! Complete strangers fell sobbing into each other’s arms. Women staggered almost fainting to the door” (Sharpe:29). The impact was so strong that, by order of the Duke of Württemberg, Schiller was placed under arrest and forbidden to write another play. Schiller took flight and left for Stuttgart. The main reason for this hysteria was the provocative inquiries into the existence of god by its two main characters: the brothers Karl and Franz. Karl is the much loved and respected first son. His quest is one of revolutionary anarchy. But unlike Franz, his real battles are taking place within his own conscience. Franz is the universally despised materialist and villain who is ruthlessly in pursuit of wealth and power. These two characters are rivals for their frail father’s (Old Moor) affection and when this is not forthcoming, embark on individual paths of deceit and destruction. Both confront their internal demons and both defiantly come to their own distinct conclusions. Written in the late eighteenth century, it is a play that looks at the nature of man as being subject to emotions, acting both irrationally and rationally using his idiosyncratic sense of reason and logic. Like Old Moor, god is distant and ineffectual leaving the protagonists ultimately responsible for their own actions. It is a play that sets the tone for the internalization of moral dilemmas and the voice of reason: the stark awareness of conscience. It is also a complex investigation into the notions of good and evil.

Two years after writing
The Robbers, Schiller explained his ideas about the role of theatre in his essay The Stage as a Moral Institution (1784). In it he states “Both laws and religion are strengthened by a union with the stage” (Gerould:250). The stage he believed was a place where people can “hear the truth”, where “purer and better principles and motives” can be discussed, and “opinions about governments and classes might be reformed”, as well as it being “a great school of practical wisdom, a guide for civil life, and a key to the mind”(250-254). The stage, he believed, should ultimately act as a “moral force” by reinforcing the religious principles which civil society abides. But his idea that the stage is the “handmaid of religion and philosophy” (251) presents some major conflicts of interest, as the two are not necessarily always aligned with each other, including during his time - the Enlightenment.

We recognise the Enlightenment as an intellectually fertile period when fresh ideas in philosophy, science and the arts began to filter out into the public arena challenging old currents of thought, practices and belief systems. With the culmination of previous knowledge and experience, there was a new optimistic attitude to the world of ideas and possibilities. New lines of thought were wearing down institutionalised traditions. Brash and diverse approaches to old institutions were setting the stage for even greater change to come. Amongst its achievements, it emancipated science and intellectual life from the ecclesiastical clutches of the church and thus opening the way for broader and at times radical discourses to cultivate.

The Enlightenment was a milestone in human history, one that has, perhaps, yet to be surpassed and one worth revisiting and expanding on. Michel Onfray is resolute; “We can and must subscribe to the Enlightenment project which remains as viable as ever” so that we as a species can lift ourselves out of our “infantile condition” and into “adulthood” (4). Christopher Hitchens exclaims “we are in need of a renewed enlightenment” (283) and finds it “of interest… how many great minds thought alike, and intersected with eachother” during the eighteenth century (266). One example of this intersection is that of philosopher Immanuel Kant and Schiller. Kant, though religious, “overthrew the cosmological proof of God” (265) challenging the idea that religion and only religion can form the foundation for what is considered moral behaviour. Kant’s basis for morality, says Dawkins, was “duty for duty’s sake rather than for God’s” as seen in his golden rule to “act only on that maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will that it should become a universal law” (231). The idea is that despite a person being detached from religion or god, one is able – and has a duty – to use reason to autonomously come to the conclusion that it is best to behave with scruples in the interest of both oneself and for the benefit of others. “Moral autonomy is the self-legislation of practical reason in a sensible rational human being. Schiller takes this concept from Kant” (Roehr:120). Therefore if we have “moral autonomy” and “practical reason” as well as the ability to act sensibly and rationally then perhaps an approach based on atheism could reasonably be a solution when the idea of god comes into question.

Writers and thinkers of all persuasions, during this time, paid close scrutiny, in particular, to the pious and religious institutions, something not lost on Schiller. He notes in the preface to
The Robbers; “These days it is in such good taste to exercise one’s sarcasm at the expense of religion that it is practically impossible to pass for a genius without deriding its most sacred truths” (Leidner:300). Being a religious man as well, his intention for writing The Robbers, he states, was firstly to copy “nature true to life” and hopefully provide “religion and morality no small revenge in depicting these malicious despisers of the holy scripture in the form of my most abominable robbers” (Leidner:300). It is ironic that by copying “nature verbatim” (300) Schiller endows his characters with the liberty of exercising their own free will which unintentionally aligns Schiller’s narrative with atheist discourse. Schiller was clearly a man of his time and The Robbers certainly challenged the dominant socio-politico-religious paradigm despite his nominal pro-religious intentions.

Despite the shock many felt initially, for many
The Robbers contains a direct revolutionary message, especially given the events that were to unfold a few years later in France. In fact, so strong was this perception that, in the aftermath of the French Revolution, Schiller was made an honorary French citizen by the French National Convention in 1792. Over ten years after its first performance its effects were still shocking people. In 1794 a young Coleridge exclaimed after reading the play, “Who is this Schiller? This convulser of the heart?” (Brandt:19). One hundred years after his birth Schiller was considered “simply a convenient emblem”, well respected and often quoted (Reed:106). Socialist revolutionary leader Rosa Luxemburg, in her letters from prison to friend Sonja Liebknecht writes that her mother thought Schiller and the Bible to be the “highest source(s) of wisdom” (Bronner:208). Luxemburg, who was actually born in Poland but relocated to Germany aged twenty-eight, was not so much interested in appropriating Schiller as the revolutionary figure but rather Schiller the idealist, though adds, “this could not be done without reading Karl Marx” (Martinson: 274). Some years later the Nazis had no qualms about appropriating Schiller as a comrade-in-arms and as a result, after World War Two, the works of Schiller were seen as tainted and “Nazi-infected” (281). It wasn’t until the 1950s that new perspectives on Schiller were investigated exploring beyond the image of the political agitator. However, it must be noted, the German Democratic Republic continued to view Schiller as a heroic symbol of communist ideals (281).

Post World War Two,
The Robbers is rarely performed and investigations into Schiller’s work are largely scholarly and intellectual endeavours. Some scholars suggest, “more research is needed on performances of his plays and their reception” in order to explore more fully the continued impact of Schiller (293). In February 2008 the University of Toronto in Canada produced an ambitious interpretation of The Robbers set in a high school classroom. The rewritten script, commissioned by The Gate Theatre London in 1995, shortens the play by half. They appear to be following the trend that “theatres seem to have few scruples in refashioning Schiller’s plays in the style of the day, to be sure, this can uncover new aspects of his texts” (290). Indeed post-production notes by Director Johanna Schall (Bertolt Brecht’s grand-daughter) illustrate the issues of god and religion caused no great fuss. Apart from suggesting the story of Karl and Franz is fundamentally the biblical parable of the lost son according to Luke and that religion (and the Law) are merely “social constraints” to an individuals pursuit of happiness; the religious question was not considered of paramount importance, certainly not shocking or outrageous. Discussions appear to focus more on issues such as fathers, happiness, robbery and the structure and historical context of the play. Statistics from Schall’s audience survey accounts (in order) that 153 people thought the play was about fathers, 145 thought it was about death and interestingly in third position, only 113 thought it was about god. A review from The Varsity (University of Toronto’s student newspaper) condescendingly concluded this rewritten version of The Robbers while enjoyable to watch holds “ideas and ideology easily held by the young” (11.2.08). Although Schall points out the discussions were “very exciting and quite wild” it, unsurprisingly, was not received in the same vein as the original production and the topic of atheism hardly even mentioned.

The Robbers and Contemporary Atheism

The attacks and accusations toward Schiller as a dangerous blasphemer, in relation to the content of The Robbers, is predominantly because his characters Karl and Franz asks the hard questions concerning God that even gods representatives (the priest and Pastor Moser) are unable to answer satisfactorily. The fact that Karl sees the error of his ways and returns to a life of law-abiding piety while Franz commits suicide -metaphorically as a sign of atonement for his transgressions - was unconvincing to the plays eighteenth century audience. The audience appeared to react and remember only the relentless bombardment of what is essentially atheistic rhetoric. Writing in 1869 Thomas Carlyle points out that at the time of The Robbers first short season, Schiller was “accused of having injured the cause of morality” by providing a dissenting model of behaviour for the youth to follow which can only lead to their untimely self destruction (Carlyle:36). The question then arises, how is god represented by Schiller and what is Karl and Franz’s attitude to god?

The father figure is important to both Franz and Karl and operates as a metaphor for a frail absent god. The father according to Onfray, “is the incarnate locus of religion and therefore of politics and theocracy” (203). Karl refers to his father, Old Moor, as “god-like” several times; “that man shall be my friend, my angel, my god – I will worship him!” (Act 1:Sc 2). When he thinks his god-like father has rejected him he sinks into a world of confusion and cynicism, rejecting his Christian god in the process. He is a man who has a strong complex sense of morality and fairness. He is a revolutionary whose fundamental aim is to restore balance and equality within the community by directly attacking the corrupt hierarchies of church and state. The problem he faces is that with no god on hand to provide a moral foundation or anchor he is left to his own devises to make sense of the world and along with Franz are “at the mercy of their own extreme temperaments” (Sharpe:14). In turn, he then becomes almost deified by his fellow robbers who all take the oath of “loyalty and obedience” to Karl “til death” (Act 2: Sc 1). But Karl is no god as we find out. He is continually haunted by the memory of his “god-like” father and the omnipresence of his Christian god.

Despite this, he nevertheless holds onto his strong sense of individual morality, as seen in Act 2 Scene 3, when he dismisses fellow robber Shufterle who callously makes light of throwing a screaming baby into flames. Sounding god-like himself he warns the members of his band whom he suspects are like Shufterle; “But I shall come amongst you, and terrible shall be my judgement upon you.” (Act 2:Sc 3). Immediately after this denunciation his soliloquy exposes a mere mortal struggling with the prevalence of a miserable reality of “pestilence… famine… floods, murder of children, of women, of the sick” and so on, in front of his own eyes. “How can I prevent it? How can you prevent it…?” he asks a vacant god (Act 2:Sc 3). Just as he is limited in his power to stop wanton destruction within his own microcosmic community of robbers how could god possibly make right the wrongs of the whole world? Karl makes an important realisation that the concept of a god that allows such misery to occur and doesn’t intervene to stop it is an illogical and flawed concept. Interestingly though the comforting idea of a god still has a strong grip on him contributing further to his troubled mind. Karl’s train of thought had already shifted in the direction of atheism. Unknown to Karl – and prevented by Schiller – was the concept that atheism and morality can coexist. Could atheism have been the answer Karl was really looking for?

Franz’s Machiavellian nature has little to do with the fact he ridicules god and religion at every opportunity. It is his nature and lust for power that dictates his actions. The outrage over this play is partly due to Franz’s frenzied tirade on religion and an invisible god. As the stereotype atheist, the force and length that Franz goes to make his point far outweighs his dramatic demise by his own hands, surreptitiously as a symbol of universal justice. Perhaps once again it is simply because Schiller gives voice to these poignant questions that the viewing public at the time was so outraged. Franz has no love for his father or for the almighty father. He has no desire for love from anybody and seeks power and possession – whether its Old Moor’s castle and money or Amalia (Karl’s melancholic love interest). So what does the father symbolise in
The Robbers and how is that then related to the idea of god?

Old Moor and god are two traditional representatives of patriarchal established order in the world. Old Moor is weak and old and no longer has the ability to restrain either son; the same is inferred in relation to god. Lesley Sharpe observes what Old Moor “represents to them is more important than what he is”. For Franz, she continues, he represents an order “which deprives him of power, money and rank” while to Karl he represents “stability, continuity and a haven from the turbulent world” (Sharpe:16). But Franz tries to kill Old Moor and Karl accidentally succeeds in causing his sudden death upon revealing his disguise. And since both brothers continually try to provoke a response from god, the ultimate father, there is a direct correlation between Old Moor and god and their respective inept weaknesses. Old Moor can be seen as a metaphor for god who also comes under intense scrutiny. And perhaps the frightening thing for its original eighteenth century audience was the very suggestion that god was weak, ineffectual and powerless; in affect non existent. This idea, observes Sharpe, poses “an existential question” for Franz and Karl (18) and, we can presume for the audience. It postulates the idea that a world without a father or god leaves individuals and societies without a moral compass though, at the same time, illustrates the vast range of free, unrestricted thought is possible, as imperfect as it may be at times.

The moral compass that religion claims to hold appears, to contemporary atheists, to have been lost sometime ago, if it ever held it at all. The world’s woes are not linked to atheism in fact, exclaims Onfray, it’s “because of God’s existence (that) everything is permitted”(42). Historically, he further asserts, if religious leaders had actively chosen a path of “peace love and tolerance, we would have known of it, witnessed it” and thus be compelled to “support the three religions on the basis of their principles” (175). History, he says, tends to prove quite the opposite. Hitchens scoffs at the idea that the devoutly pious “possess moral advantages that others can only envy” (32). For example, the
Bible he declares, contains “a warrant for trafficking in humans, for ethnic cleansing, for slavery, for bride-price, and for indiscriminate massacre”, just for starters (102). Dawkins remarks that humankind must have significantly “low self-regard” to think if our world was without god or religion everybody would automatically become “callous and selfish hedonists, with no kindness, no charity, no generosity”; basically void of “goodness” (227). If this perception, to an extent, is true today, it was even more so the case in 1783.

The Robbers presents a reflection of a society in the grips of a dense intellectual flow of new ideas through the community, one that invariably includes the concept of god being non-existent. Unfortunately this community has no idea or vision of how to live without god’s instruction. This may be why Karl, in the end, returns to the very order that he knows is corrupt and callous. There is a sense of the unresolved in The Robbers here, of “social criticism having led into a blind alley” (Sharpe:23). The world of The Robbers clearly has some serious socio-economic problems that need addressing but how is it to be done? Part of the answer may be to dispose of an ineffectual absent god and its corrupted representative institutions and replace it with a new secular system. Schiller’s preoccupation with individual autonomy and freedom in his writings would suggest that both Karl and Franz exercise this freedom but are led astray by their own unchecked emotions and actions. Karl is by far the most destructive and dangerous of the two but this path is clearly not necessarily the only option. Is it that Schiller couldn’t possibly even conceive that Karl could realise the error of his murderous ways, not believe in god yet still be a good and moral person? Was this too scandalous a thought to even entertain in eighteenth century Germany? It would be about one hundred years before Nietzsche would propose that “we can choose not to choose” (Onfray:35). Perhaps without a viable, readily available, easily digested alternative, religion continues to hold it ground and powerful sway despite its defiance of logic and reason. Was Schiller’s Karl heading toward atheism but, like many atheist-like characters before him, was required to capitulate back to the established order or (like Franz) die, before the curtain fell?

In many respects Schiller presents Franz as the stereotype atheist. He constantly lies and deceives his father and attempts to deceive and steal Amalia from Karl. He emotionally manipulates Hermann – the bastard son of a nobleman – to swear his allegiance and help destroy Karl. He tries to hurry the immanent death of Old Moor and imprisons him in order to become the power-crazy Master of the house. And that’s only in the first two acts. Once in power Franz proceeds to blackmail Amalia to be his wife. He forces himself onto her only to be met with a slap in the face. Franz mocks and denounces god with great vitriolic fervour, though not without a sense of uncertainty. Realising his fate is sealed, both earthly and beyond, he strangles himself with wire from his clothing with his final words to god(?), “Ha! You then, take pity on me!” (Act 5:Sc 1). His behaviour is clearly manipulative, callous, degenerate and selfish to the point of his own destruction but can we blame Franz’s atheism for his actions or is it simply his own distorted reasoning? Atheism according to Onfray is “the product of a verbal creation by the manufacturers of God” (16). Franz, the stereotype atheist was in no sense the first in this mould to appear on stage.

Heaven, Hell and The Robbers


Most of the main characters in
The Robbers are prone to appealing to heaven and hell at any given moment but this could have more to do with the rhetorical nature of Schiller’s style than his religious convictions. Also it was most likely just part of the common vernacular of the day. Perhaps as well it was the only moral paradigm in which they knew to operate within or were prepared to operate – not forgetting the various atheist texts and philosophical discourse circulating at the time. Franz is inexorable and prescient when he curses those who “corrupt our fantasy with horrific fairy tales and impress our soft brains with hideous images of judgements and punishments” which serve only to “bar the way to boldest resolutions, bind our awakening reason in fetters of superstitious darkness” (Act 4:Sc 2). To the contemporary atheist the concepts of heaven and hell are extremely questionable. Hitchens’ response is unrelenting; “Nothing proves the man-made character of religion as obviously the sick mind that designed hell, unless it is the sorely limited mind that has failed to describe heaven – except as a place of either worldly comfort, eternal tedium, or continual relish in the torture of others” (219). Heaven and angels, says Onfray, are “creations of fantasy”. The angel is essentially an “anti-man” ideal and heaven or paradise, “anti-world” (97). The religious moral paradigm suggests everything we say, do and think has eternal repercussions, not so much in this world but in the afterlife. This very idea comes under fire from Dawkins suggesting; “We humans give ourselves such airs even aggrandizing our poky little ‘sins’ to the level of cosmic significance” (238). The conclusions Franz reaches are clearly unsustainable and immoral, that is a certainty. But the conclusions Karl reaches are more complicated because he sought a workable alternative to the dominant paradigm but was not able to conceive of one apart from a more overtly violent and lawless reality. The choices given to them by god’s earthly representatives are limited.

In Act 2 Scene 3 a Priest pays a visit to Karl and his robbers’ hideout in the forests of Bohemia to offer a pardon for the lawless deeds and demand they give themselves up. He arrives with the full backing of the establishment; “out there are seventeen hundred men, set to guard every hair of my head” (Act 2: Sc 3). With the comfort of this protection he begins with a tirade of abuse aimed at the robbers; “poisonous brood of vipers… plague upon the face on mankind – generation of hell” and so on. He seeks only to convince them to come crawling back to the “Holy Mother Church” where the “way to rank and honour shall be open” to all of them. His real motivation is not to save them from god but from the law! By contrast, in Act 5 Scene 1 Pastor Moser is summoned by Franz – after he had a nightmare about being judged by God.
Pastor Moser (a Jesuit?) throws down a Pascal’s Wager-like challenge to the confused Franz, “If you stand firm in death, if your principles do not desert you even then, then the victory is yours; but if in the hour of death you feel but the slightest qualm, then woe unto you! You have been deceived” (Act 5:Sc 3). The choices offered by the Pastor are clear, follow the righteous godly law-abiding path and go to heaven or face judgement in hell. There is no in-between. Franz at first thinks he can defy heaven its “victory” and hell its “mockery” by ordering Daniel to stab him. Daniel clearly in fear of damnation himself flees with god speed not wishing to jeopardise his chances for eternal bliss. Karl chooses to return to the fold while Franz takes his chance with divine justice. Amalia, living a chaste existence, believes she will go to heaven. Old Moor hopes to go to heaven but fears, because of his failure with his sons, he may go to hell. The characters in
The Robbers are always conscious of the afterlife and whether their behaviour in this life warrants eternal agony or ecstasy after death.

Christianity, Islam and Judaism, according to Onfray, “call on their faithful to renounce life in the here and now” (66) and focus on a “tinsel afterlife” (198). This focus on the mythical hereafter, he asserts quite simply, “leads to denial, contempt or hatred of the here and now” (198). The theory of what Hitchens calls “the doctrine of eternal reward and/or punishment” (205) teaches that if you follow god’s word to the letter, however you interpret it, you will automatically be immortalised. Therefore death doesn’t happen to you really because you make the transition into the next world and “live” forever. You likewise “live” forever, in a sense, if you don’t follow god’s law; unfortunately it will be in the torturously sadistic world of hell. A martyr holds that duty to god is always first priority, they choose martyrdom with the understanding they will be “rewarded in the gardens of Paradise” (Dawkins:308). “The idea of immortality” says Dawkins, “survives and spreads because it caters to wishful thinking” (190). Karl in
The Robbers, reflecting on his own failures, ponders this very question; “Why this ideal of unattained perfection? This looking to another world for what we have failed to achieve in this? (Act 4:Sc 5) Is the focus on life after death really just the avoidance of facing the subject of death itself? Is death the real issue?

Death, Beckett, Conscience and Reason, Corruption, Heaven and Hell Rethought and The Robbers

Onfray declares, Christianity (like other monotheistic religions), are “fatally fixated on death. It loves death, cherishes death; it exults in death, is fascinated by death.”(176). Since the time of Constantine – the first Christian Emperor of Rome - in the fourth century “armed with this ontological asset” of god’s word, Christians “very early began to sell their souls” in a grab for power and wealth (182). Inflicting death in the name of god has been part and parcel of monotheism ever since. “History bears witness: millions of dead in the name of God, millions on every continent and in every century” (182). If monotheistic faith is so ingrained and apparently quite deadly, can we enter into a new post-religious era anytime soon? No says Hitchens “not until we get over our fear of death and of the dark and of the unknown, and of eachother” (12). The fear of death perhaps is pure existential angst which if confronted will reveal, “the truth of existence seen… in the glare of a horrifyingly simple insight” (Dobrez:91). That is, we exist and beyond that there is nothing.

The plays of Samuel Beckett often challenge us, for example, to confront death and consider the possibility of existence with a definitive end.
Rockaby (1981) expresses frustrated acceptance toward the idea of existence and nothingness simultaneously. The life-weary female protagonist’s repetitiously fading pleas for “more” (275-280) underlie the anticipated “close of a long day” (275-281) that quickly approaches which “in the end” (275-281) produces the defiant “fuck life” (282) as if life, somewhat pessimistically, amounts to nothing in the end. Her life long search for her mother, or maybe someone like herself, or simply herself has produced no tangible results. She frustratingly waits for the void to “Rock her off” (282). The “Speaker” in A Piece of Monologue (1980) faces a blank wall in a dimly lit room and begins, “Birth was the death of him” (265). All alone, having cut himself off from the outside world, he muses on birth and death initially and then finally just death. The inevitable force of death is powerful and pulls him, “Into the black vast. Nothing there. Nothing stirring… into the dark whole again. No. No such thing as whole” (267). And is the situation in which the three protagonists in Play (1963) find themselves in purgatory? hell? or perhaps a comedic metaphor for our earthly existence, perpetually moving in circles, replaying events over and over in our heads, with no solution, for eternity. The character Man asks, “Am I as much as being seen?” (157) alluding to the reality of the fleeting nature of existence.

Through Beckett’s peripheral vision we can perceive “the power and the reality of existence, even if the meaning of that existence remains unattainable” (Davis et al:65). The inability of our language and knowledge to reveal an actual, tangible or visceral understanding of death, and therefore life, allows for perpetual speculation leaving a gap which religion attempts to fill. Franz is merciless in his summation of life and death; “man is born of filth and wades a little while in filth, and makes filth, and rots away again in filth, til at last he is no more that the muck that sticks to the soles of his great-grandsons shoes” (Act 4: Sc 5). It is a view that, in some ways resembles Beckett’s in that there is the distinct absence of god and no heaven or hell to look forward to. We live, we die. But while Schiller gives Franz that glimmer of doubt in his last moments, Beckett presents us with is the possibility that there is nothing after death and leaves us to contemplate and accept that very real possibility.

That an afterlife, of either heaven or hell is the only options on offer from the priest and pastor in
The Robbers, is perhaps indicative of the power of denial and the fear of death instilled in the minds of the devoutly pious. The clergy in The Robbers are clearly speaking from a position of privilege and power that ultimately seeks to maintain the socio/political order. This is one of the reasons they cannot be taken seriously. Being an intrinsic part of the corrupt power hierarchy, how would they be judged by their god and where would they end up in the afterlife? The corruption of the church and its links to the state is well documented from its very beginnings, through the medieval period, the fascist regimes of Musssolini and Nazi Germany to modern Christian, Muslim and Jewish fundamentalist regimes and organisations globally.

That religion was intrinsically linked to the corrupt power structure was undeniable and astutely observed by Karl. His actions speak of revolution against the established ruling classes - “death or liberty!” Though he, personally, may be having a crisis of faith throughout most of the play, he nevertheless is at war with those immediately responsible for the misery and suffering present around him. He wears as trophies jewellery taken from his most prized victims; a ruby from a politician, a diamond from a Minister of Finance. Provocatively he tells the priest, “this agate I wear in honour of one of your cloth, whom I strangled with my own hands” (Act 2:Sc 3). One thing is clear; the perceived enemies are the church and state.

Karl acts within the confines of some sort of customized ethical code that justifies violence and theft against the rich and powerful; in essence he is akin to the medieval English legend of Robin Hood. An example is in Act 2 Scene 3, leading a charge to save his favourite fellow bandit Roller from the hangman’s noose, he consequently burns down a town killing eighty three people: children, the elderly and even a pregnant woman. Despite much personal distress on hearing about the aftermath, he justifies the act as being committed out of love and loyalty to Roller. But when other fellow robber Schufterle expresses mocking contempt for the dead, Karl curses his inhumanity, dismissing him immediately from the group. Karl is a man who is both socially and politically aware and clearly he has a conscience, “Oh my treacherous conscience – Take notice of what I say!” (Act 5: Sc 2) and this is the bane of his melancholy.

Conscience and reason play a major role in the development of character in both Franz and Karl. Franz fiendishly notes, “Conscience… yes indeed a most admirable device to keep fools respectful and to hold down the mob, so the clever people can live in better comfort” (Act 1:Sc 2). In his room, continuing this line of thought leads to further deviations from morality; “What can reason or religion do to stay the monster’s icy embrace?” (Act 2:Sc 1). Franz actively seeks to cause disharmony and is at war with nature. It is nothing short of “an attempt to deceive the world by perverting the course of nature.” (Panterfield:456). But who has he deceived if not only himself in the end? Perhaps it is what we leave behind that lives on rather than Beckett’s nothingness. In a very real sense we live on through our ideas, our genes and through minute cells that we pass on. These in essence are the contributions we make to human evolution. Thus heaven and hell may really just be the two possibilities of humanities earthly outcomes. We end up in a hellish reality or one that is heavenly. Which ideas, genes and cells triumph will ultimately decide our collective future.

Compare Franz with our first encounter, in the text, with Karl, engrossed in a book. Karl is a man of dualities, feeling an accord with nature and a discord with humanity. He attempts to use reason to justify his lawless actions only to find his conscience demands more answers; “There is such divine harmony in the world of inanimate nature, why such discord in the world of reason? … I am my heaven and my hell” (Act 4:Sc 5) This is the point, that we, individually and collectively, ultimately are our own heaven and hell. Both men understand the power which they possess to shape events but it is only Karl who acknowledges his conscience and seeks answers to the turbulence taking place inside his mind. The freedom of the will has the power to move in either direction; absolutely in one direction, as is the case with Franz, or simultaneously in both, as with Karl. From a contemporary atheist perspective Karl only had to renounce violence from his life to be on the path to greater harmony with the world. He had already realised the fiction of god and the corruption of the Church and state. Instead of believing the improbable suggestion that, “two men such as I would destroy the whole moral order of creation” (Act 5:Sc 2) it would be more accurate to suggest if everybody was like him then maybe we would have a hellish reality. Dawkins muses “life is as meaningful, as full, and as wonderful as we choose to make it” (360). Perhaps atheism (without the violence) was the answer to his existential angst and longing, because then he would pass on his ideas and help shape the meaningful and wonderful future? This would help create a heavenly utopia on earth. As it turns out in the end, with Karl’s surprisingly swift return to the fold at the conclusion of the
The Robbers, Schiller simply reiterates the viewpoint that disobeying those in power is akin to disobeying god. Karl then simply perpetuates the corrupt established order and thus ends up contributing to the path toward a future hellish dystopian reality.